The System Challenge

Mental health systems face structural challenges that technology alone cannot solve. But technology may help at specific points.

160K+
provider shortage
HRSA, 2024
23+ hrs
average psychiatric boarding
ACEP, 2023
60%
counties without psychiatrist
HRSA data
97%
reduction in state beds since 1955
TAC

Where Technology Can Help

Technology cannot create more providers or beds. But it can address specific points of system strain:

What Technology Cannot Do

Be realistic about limitations:

  • Cannot replace workforce. Technology augments; it doesn't substitute for trained providers.
  • Cannot create beds. Psychiatric boarding requires physical infrastructure and staffing.
  • Cannot replace therapeutic relationship. Hybrid models consistently outperform pure digital.
  • Cannot safely handle crisis alone. AI crisis detection is unreliable.
  • Cannot solve engagement. 80%+ of users stop using apps within 2 weeks.

Implementation Considerations

1. Start with Clear Use Cases

Don't adopt technology in search of a problem. Identify specific points of system strain where technology has evidence of benefit.

2. Evaluate Evidence Carefully

Many digital mental health vendors make claims not supported by evidence. Ask for:

  • Peer-reviewed publications on the specific product
  • Real-world engagement data (not just trial data)
  • Independent evaluation (not just company-funded)
  • Crisis protocol documentation

3. Plan for Integration

Digital tools that don't integrate with clinical workflow tend to fail:

  • EHR integration for data sharing
  • Staff training and buy-in
  • Clear referral pathways
  • Monitoring and outcome tracking

4. Prioritize Safety

Any digital tool used with patients must have:

  • Robust crisis protocols
  • Clear disclaimers about limitations
  • Human oversight mechanisms
  • Escalation pathways

5. Consider Equity

Digital tools risk widening disparities if not designed carefully:

  • Digital divide (not everyone has smartphones)
  • Literacy requirements
  • Language and cultural appropriateness
  • Algorithmic bias testing

Models Worth Studying

NHS IAPT

The UK's Improving Access to Psychological Therapies program treats 1.5+ million people annually using stepped care with digital tools at lower steps.

Key lessons: Self-referral, measurement-based care, clear step-up criteria, national standards.

More details →

CCBHCs

Certified Community Behavioral Health Centers show 60% increase in persons served, 12% reduction in ED visits, 18% reduction in hospitalizations.

Key lessons: Comprehensive services, 24/7 crisis, integration with primary care.

More details →

Digital Clinic Model

Dr. Torous's "Digital Clinic" combines app-based tools (mindLAMP) with clinician support and digital navigators.

Key lessons: Hybrid model, digital phenotyping, measurement-based care, digital navigator role.

More on Dr. Torous's work →

Crisis Stabilization Units

23-hour observation units as alternatives to ED boarding and inpatient admission for many presentations.

Technology role: Telepsychiatry, monitoring, handoff coordination.

More details →

Further Resources